Catalyst 9200 vs Cisco Meraki: Cloud Management Comparison

 Catalyst 9200 vs Cisco Meraki: Cloud Management Comparison

Cloud management has become a pivotal aspect of modern network infrastructure, offering centralized control, simplified deployment, and enhanced visibility. Cisco offers two powerful solutions in this space: the Catalyst 9200 series switches with Cisco DNA Center and the Cisco Meraki series with the Meraki Dashboard. This article compares the cloud management capabilities of Cisco Catalyst 9200 and Cisco Meraki to help you decide which solution is best suited for your enterprise needs.

1. Overview of Cisco Catalyst 9200

The Cisco Catalyst 9200 series switches are designed to deliver enterprise-class access switching with simplicity, security, and scalability. They integrate with Cisco DNA Center for cloud management, providing advanced analytics, automation, and policy enforcement.

Key Features

  • High Performance: Robust performance for wired and wireless networks.

  • Advanced Security: Features such as Cisco TrustSec, MACsec encryption, and 802.1X authentication.

  • Scalability: Supports stackable configurations with Cisco StackWise technology.

  • Centralized Management: Managed through Cisco DNA Center.

2. Overview of Cisco Meraki

Cisco Meraki offers cloud-managed networking solutions that simplify deployment and management through an intuitive, web-based dashboard. The Meraki portfolio includes switches, access points, and security appliances.

Key Features

  • Cloud Management: Centralized management through the Meraki Dashboard.

  • Ease of Deployment: Simplified setup and configuration.

  • Scalability: Easily scales to accommodate growing network demands.

  • Advanced Analytics: Provides detailed insights into network performance and usage.

3. Comparison of Cloud Management Capabilities

Management Interface

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200 (DNA Center)

Cisco Meraki (Meraki Dashboard)

Management Platform

Cisco DNA Center, CLI, WebUI

Meraki Dashboard (cloud-based)

Ease of Use

Moderate (requires network expertise)

High (user-friendly, intuitive interface)

Configuration

CLI, WebUI, DNA Center

Cloud-based, web interface

Monitoring and Analytics

Advanced with DNA Center

Advanced with built-in analytics

Security Features

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200

Cisco Meraki

Encryption

MACsec, IPSec

WPA3, VPN support

Access Control

Cisco TrustSec, 802.1X authentication

Identity-based policies, 802.1X

Threat Detection

Advanced threat detection tools

Built-in security features, integrated with Cisco Umbrella

Firewall

Stateful firewall capabilities

Layer 7 firewall

Performance and Scalability

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200

Cisco Meraki

Throughput

High throughput for enterprise networks

High throughput, optimized for cloud

Stacking

Cisco StackWise-160 for up to 160 Gbps

Meraki virtual stacking for simplified management

Port Density

Up to 48 ports per switch

Varies by model, up to 48 ports per switch

Uplinks

1G, 10G, and 25G options

1G, 10G, 25G, and 100G options

Automation and Policy Management

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200

Cisco Meraki

Automation

Advanced automation with DNA Center

Simplified automation through the Meraki Dashboard

Policy Management

Detailed policy enforcement

Easy-to-use policy configuration

Updates

Automated updates and patches

Seamless, cloud-delivered updates

Cost Considerations

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200

Cisco Meraki

Initial Purchase Cost

Higher initial cost due to advanced features

Competitive pricing with subscription model

Operational Costs

Lower with efficient management tools

Potentially higher due to cloud subscriptions

Total Cost of Ownership

Balanced with robust support options

Higher TCO with cloud management fees

4. Use Case Scenarios

Cisco Catalyst 9200

  • Large Enterprises: Ideal for organizations requiring high performance, advanced security, and scalability.

  • Mixed Wired and Wireless Environments: Suitable for networks needing robust wired and wireless integration.

  • High Security Requirements: Perfect for organizations with stringent security policies and compliance needs.

Cisco Meraki

  • Small to Medium-Sized Businesses: Ideal for businesses looking for easy deployment and management.

  • Cloud-First Organizations: Perfect for companies that prefer cloud-managed solutions.

  • Rapid Deployment Needs: Suitable for environments that need quick and scalable network setups.

5. Detailed Feature Comparison

Management and Monitoring

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200 (DNA Center)

Cisco Meraki (Meraki Dashboard)

Management Interface

Cisco DNA Center, WebUI, CLI

Meraki Dashboard (cloud-based)

Ease of Use

Moderate (requires network expertise)

High (user-friendly, intuitive interface)

Automation

Advanced automation capabilities

Simplified automation capabilities

Monitoring and Analytics

Detailed analytics and monitoring tools

Comprehensive monitoring capabilities

Security and Compliance

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200

Cisco Meraki

Compliance

Meets enterprise compliance standards

Meets enterprise compliance standards

Access Control

Role-based access control (RBAC), TrustSec

Identity-based policies, integrated access control

Encryption

MACsec encryption

WPA3, VPN

Threat Detection

Integrated with Cisco security solutions

Built-in security features, Cisco Umbrella integration

Performance

Feature

Cisco Catalyst 9200

Cisco Meraki

Throughput

High throughput suitable for enterprise

High throughput, optimized for cloud

Latency

Low latency for critical applications

Low latency, optimized for cloud services

Scalability

StackWise technology for easy scaling

Easily scalable via cloud management

Summary of Cloud Management Comparison

Aspect

Cisco Catalyst 9200 (DNA Center)

Cisco Meraki (Meraki Dashboard)

Management Interface

Advanced with DNA Center

Intuitive with Meraki Dashboard

Security

Advanced security features

Robust security capabilities

Performance

High throughput, low latency

High throughput, optimized for cloud

Cost

Higher initial cost, lower operational costs

Competitive pricing, higher TCO with subscriptions

Conclusion

Both the Cisco Catalyst 9200 and Cisco Meraki series offer robust cloud management capabilities, but they cater to different needs and preferences. The Catalyst 9200 series is ideal for large enterprises requiring advanced security, high performance, and centralized management through Cisco DNA Center. In contrast, Meraki’s cloud-managed approach is perfect for small to medium-sized businesses and cloud-first organizations looking for easy deployment, scalability, and simplified management through the Meraki Dashboard.

 

Choosing the right solution depends on your specific requirements, budget, and long-term network management strategy. By carefully evaluating these factors, you can select the cloud management solution that best meets your organization’s needs for reliability, security, and performance.

  • ORM Systems: Leading IT solution provider for global businesses and public entities. Access Cisco routers, switches, and other IT products here!

     

ormsystems

Global IT hardware solution provider

Related post